All are Andrew/Jesse. Additional pairings noted.
All Fruit by Emilys_List
(+ Emma/Andrew/Jesse, Emma/Andrew, Emma/Jesse) NC-17, chaptered
[On comparing kissing Andrew Garfield and Ryan Gosling] “Apples and oranges, you know? I love all fruit." - Emma Stone. A love story about time and the way we change.
All The Stars And Bleeding Hearts by torakowalski
(+ Emma/Joe, Justin/Britney) NC-17, oneshot [long]
Notting Hill AU. In which Jesse runs a bookstore, Andrew is a famous film star and they’re both faily dorks in love.
Aspects by Poose
NC-17, oneshot [long]
For the prompt: "Andrew makes Jesse watch his films during sex."
Forever Can Never Be Long Enough, Or The Earl Of Epsom Takes A Husband by torakowalski
(+ misc) NC-17, chaptered-length
Regency AU. When Andrew Garfield, the new Earl of Epsom, returns from the Peninsula War to find his ancestral home mortgaged to the hilt, he must marry Jesse Eisenberg, his parents’ mysterious ward, in order to save his family from ruin.
The Giraffe Notes by jeyhawk
The impossible love story of a mouse and a giraffe featuring a crush that last a decade, a very grateful movie star, the fine art of falling in love over the internet, a possibly naughty tattoo, three awesome friends, cats, nerves, and a spectacular first date.
If you can't be touched by ragandboneshopoftheheart
R, oneshot [long]
Andrew and Jesse are cast as the leads in an adaptation of classic gay novel Giovanni's Room. Over months of filming and sharing an apartment in Paris, the overlap between their feelings and their characters' becomes hard for them to handle.
In motion by Yellowwolf
NC-17, oneshot [long]
Of course, out of everyone on the plane, Jesse has to be seated next to the person who has his book. If this is the universe’s way of a cosmic joke, then Jesse isn’t finding it very funny.
The Long Affair by Emilys_List
Jesse and Andrew hang out, have sex, fight, and fall in love, from Boston to Los Angeles to Europe. Oh and they also make and promote and are awarded for a movie called The Social Network. Perhaps you've heard of it.
she's so beautiful (and i tell her every day) by Anonymous
Prompt: I honestly just want girl!Andrew-on-girl!Jesse (or vice versa, WHATEVER!) Porn would be amazing, but a background story would be pretty sweet too.
Shelter by harriet_vane
From the kinkmeme prompt: Some sort of AU vaguely based on Shelter! For whatever reason, Jesse has to take care of Hallie and give up his dream of being an actor. He ends up working in a dead end job when former, now successful friend (Andrew) returns home. They fall in love, etc, only Jesse can't go away with him because he has a responsibility to his family. CUE ANGST.
Ten Cups of Coffee (A Love Story) by harriet_vane
PG-13, oneshot [long]
A Starbucks + grad school AU
Andrew Garfield: "There was a very American, romanticized idea that I had in my head about what it would be like to work in a coffee shop. I thought of coffee shops as the kind of place where you met really smart, interesting, quirky [people] with thick, black-rimmed glasses."
Untitled (#2) by wordgasmic
The one where Jesse is Andrew's good little housewife, dress and all.
you know my wandering days are over by pidgeoned
(+ Armie/Max) PG-13, oneshot [long]
Andrew and Jesse meet in the lift. Repeatedly.